What is ‘Just Cause’ for Dismissal?
There is a reason that Canadian courts refer to just cause for dismissal as the “capital punishment of employment law.” The implications can be grave.
If you are fired for just cause, you will likely face a number of problems. These can include your former employer refusing to provide severance, Service Canada denying your application for Employment Insurance (EI) benefits and potential negative work references while seeking re-employment.
Because the implications of a just cause dismissal are so severe, the law requires employers to meet a high threshold before they can successfully make this assertion. An employer that fires an employee for just cause must be able to show that the employee's conduct was of such a degree that it was no longer compatible with ongoing employment. The key is that the sanction imposed (termination) must be proportional to the misconduct in question.
In any determination of whether just cause for dismissal is a reasonable response, three questions must be answered:
What is the nature and context of the employee's misconduct?
What were the circumstances surrounding the misconduct?
Is dismissal an appropriate response?
In answering these questions, context is critical. The employee's disciplinary history, the nature of the workplace and the employer's response to similar previous acts can all play a role in determining whether a just cause dismissal will be sustained. Furthermore, the term 'misconduct' incorporates a wide range of actions including theft, dishonesty, acts of violence, chronic absenteeism, misuse of company assets, sexual harassment and social media activity.
The recent case of Phanlouvong v. Northfield Metal Products (1994) Ltd. et al highlights the critical role that context will play, and serves as a reminder of how hard a just cause dismissal is to establish. Consider the following:
Mr. Phanlouvong worked on an assembly line at a manufacturing facility operated by Northfield. In this role, he was positioned at a work station with three other employees and had a fraught relationship with one of these individuals, Mr. Bailey.
One morning prior to the commencement of his shift, Mr.Bailey passed Mr. Phanlouvong with his elbows extended, carrying dirty gloves. As he passed, Mr. Bailey knocked Mr. Phanlouvong with one of his elbows. Mr. Phanlouvong took immediate exception to this and punched Mr. Bailey in the face, breaking his safety glasses and bloodying his nose.
Following this incident, Northfield conducted an internal investigation and ultimately decided to terminate Mr. Phanlouvong's employment for just cause. Mr. Phanlouvong responded by filing a claim for wrongful dismissal, which the company vigorously fought.
At trial, the judge rejected Northfield's argument that it had just cause to fire Mr. Phanlouvong and awarded him a severance package based on 15 months' pay. In so doing, the judge found that Northfield had failed to consider whether there were any reasonable (lesser) alternatives to termination and commented that despite his misconduct:
Mr. Phanlouvong had 16 years of service with Northfield with no previous incidents of discipline of any nature, much less an incidents involving violence. His supervisors described him in evidence as an excellent employee.
The Bottom Line
As an employee, you should be aware that just cause dismissal is not easy for an employer to prove. If you are fired for just cause, it makes sense to challenge it as you have much to gain and very little to lose. If the employer cannot show that its decision was a reasonable response, you will be eligible to receive a severance package and stand a far better chance of accessing EI benefits.
As an employer, while just cause dismissal is a high threshold to meet, in certain circumstances it is the appropriate response. The three key elements that should be present prior to any decision to implement a termination for just cause are: consistent and equal treatment of staff; active and appropriate management of any acts of misconduct; and thorough documentation.
Related Articles from Our Blog
Workplace Legal Services for Employees
-
Severance Packages
If you do not have a written employment contract, you are entitled to Common Law Reasonable Notice. If you do have a written employment contract, depending on its wording, your entitlement to severance will fall into one of 3 camps.
-
Wrongful Dismissal
Wrongful dismissal cases can vary greatly and damages incurred for wrongful dismissal can, as well. Understanding the extent of your rights and entitlement can be difficult. It is always wise to consult a wrongful dismissal lawyer before taking action.
-
Constructive Dismissal
Constructive dismissal is a legal term used to describe conduct, or requirements made of you, which are so at odds with your job that it amounts to a fundamental breach of your employment contract. This breach allows you to act as though you have been fired and seek damages.
-
Employment Contract Review
If you have a new job, you may be feeling very positive about it right now but it's important to fully understand exactly what you're getting into. Your contract will be in force not just during the first exciting days at your new job, but during times of trouble and at the end of your term, whether you are fired or choose to resign.
-
Contractor Status
Many employees are not technically employees but contractors. The difference in what they do at work may be insignificant. You may not know whether you are an employee or independent contractor, or you may have been told that by being a contractor, you will have more freedom.
-
Workplace Harassment and Bullying
Legislation and workplace harassment laws, such as the Occupational Health and Safety Act (OHSA), require that all employers have anti-harassment and anti-violence policies in the workplace to protect employees. Despite these measures, workplace harassment, such as workplace sexual harassment, still occurs.
-
Canada Pension Plan Disability Claims
CPP's disability benefits are notoriously difficult to obtain. Many clients come to Vey Willetts LLP after they have been rejected, and we help them appeal the CPP's decision. Unfortunately, while they wait for their appeal, they live with delay and uncertainty.
-
Human Rights and Discrimination
Discrimination refers to an action or a decision that treats a person negatively as a result, for example, of their race, age or sex. In Ontario, the law protects against discrimination on an enumerated characteristic protected by human rights law.
-
Restrictive Covenants
If you have signed, or been presented with, an employment contract that has a restrictive covenant it is important to understand what it means and what potential liability you could face if your employer sought its enforcement against you.
-
Denial of Disability Benefits
One advantage of being an employee can be access to short and/or long-term disability benefits. Most of us may never need to rely upon these entitlements. When something goes wrong, however, it is important to ensure you and your family are provided with the financial support you need to focus on what matters: your health.
-
Workplace Privacy
Employees are entitled to a certain expectation of privacy at work. How far this extends, however, will vary. Your expectation of privacy may be affected by where you work, the type of work you perform, and workplace policies your employer may institute. Employers are also required to make all reasonable efforts to protect any private information you provide to them.
-
Pregnancy and Parental Leave
Understanding pregnancy and parental leave rights in Ontario is essential, as governed by the Employment Standards Act. Eligible employees can access up to 17 weeks of pregnancy leave and an additional 35-37 weeks of parental leave, providing crucial support during these important life stages.
-
What is 'Just Cause' for Dismissal?
If you are fired for just cause, you will likely face a number of problems. These can include your former employer refusing to provide severance, Service Canada denying your application for Employment Insurance ("EI") benefits and potential negative work references while seeking re-employment.
-
Non-Compete/Solicitation Agreements
Employers often struggle with retaining clients and customers, especially when former employees use their skills and experience to compete in the same market. To address this, employers may require employees to sign non-compete or non-solicitation agreements, which restrict former employees from competing or soliciting business from former clients.
-
Without Cause Termination and Employment Standards
Terminating an employee without cause, often due to financial or restructuring reasons, requires adherence to the Employment Standards Act, 2000. This overview explains the employer's obligations for providing notice or pay in lieu and outlines severance pay entitlements in Ontario.
-
Employment Standards Act (ESA)
The Employment Standards Act serves as the cornerstone of employment law in Ontario, setting out the minimum standards for most workplaces. It covers crucial areas such as wages, hours of work, and leaves, ensuring fair and equitable treatment for employees.
-
Types of Discrimination in the Workplace
The Ontario Human Rights Code outlines various types of workplace discrimination, stemming from negative stereotypes and biases. It covers a broad range of grounds including age, sex, race, disability, marital and family status, pregnancy, gender identity, sexual orientation, and discrimination due to association, each defined with examples to illustrate how they manifest in the workplace.
-
Vacation Pay
Navigating vacation pay in Ontario can be complex, but understanding it is crucial for both employers and employees. This guide breaks down the key aspects of vacation pay as outlined in the Employment Standards Act, 2000, ensuring clarity on what's included, what's excluded, and how it's calculated.
A Proven Track Record of Legal Success
Employment and Labour Laws are not always straightforward, but whether you are an employee or an employer, understanding your rights and duties will only stand to benefit you. Reach out to an employment lawyer or labour lawyer today if you have any questions and be sure to get what you deserve and safeguard yourself for the future. The lawyers at Vey Willetts LLP have a proven track record and are happy to assist. Our Ottawa employment lawyers and labour lawyers serve clients throughout both Ottawa and Ontario.
Call us today at 613-238-4430, 1-800-296-7989 or fill out our online form.