Ontario Employment and Labour Law Blog

Search All Articles

COVID-19 & Employment, Constructive Dismissal Kevin Patrick Robbins COVID-19 & Employment, Constructive Dismissal Kevin Patrick Robbins

Does the COVID-19 Pandemic Provide Ontario Employers with an Implied Right to Layoff Staff?

When the pandemic first began, and at various subsequent points, many Ontario employers experienced a decrease in work volume and, as a result, made the difficult decision to place their staff on temporary unpaid lay-off from work. This seemingly straightforward decision, however, has resulted for some businesses in unintended litigation. They have faced employee claims for severance on the basis that their lay-off amounted to a constructive dismissal from employment.

Read More
Accommodation, Constructive Dismissal, Human Rights Kevin Patrick Robbins Accommodation, Constructive Dismissal, Human Rights Kevin Patrick Robbins

Not Much to “Like”: Lessons from an Anti-Social Work Environment

Social media platforms moderate user-posted content to protect us from offensive, disturbing and sometimes criminal content. This process, however, is not always automatic. It often relies upon the efforts of individual workers to act as gatekeepers, keeping undesirable content at bay.

Read More
Constructive Dismissal, Workplace Harassment Kevin Patrick Robbins Constructive Dismissal, Workplace Harassment Kevin Patrick Robbins

Recognizing and Resolving Poisoned Work Environments

Employees are entitled to work in a respectful environment, free from harassment and discrimination. In circumstances where the work environment deteriorates to such an extent that it may be considered “poisonous” or “toxic”, a court will likely find that the employer’s behaviour in creating and/or condoning this environment amounted to a constructive dismissal of the affected employee.

Read More
Constructive Dismissal, Wrongful Dismissal Kevin Patrick Robbins Constructive Dismissal, Wrongful Dismissal Kevin Patrick Robbins

Putting the Brakes on Mitigation? Earnings in ‘Inferior Positions’ and Employee Severance

The Ontario Court of Appeal recently released its decision in Brake v RJ-M2R Restaurant Inc. This is an important decision for employees and employers alike as it may potentially change the way in which Ontario courts assess a wrongfully dismissed employee’s mitigation efforts and their consequent entitlement to additional severance. Mitigation refers to the obligation of dismissed employees to look for alternate comparable employment. Feldman J.A.’s concurring reasons, in particular, suggest that where a dismissed employee accepts an inferior job, any earnings therein may not count as ‘mitigation income’.

Read More
Constructive Dismissal Kevin Patrick Robbins Constructive Dismissal Kevin Patrick Robbins

Terminated: (Summary) Judgment Day

When the T-1000 came from the future to destroy John Connor, Arnie made sure he was stopped in his tracks. While employers who have to date relied upon prohibitive time and costs to deter ex-employee claims might not face the wrath that Skynet did, given the recent decision of Cloutier v. Q Residential LP Corp, 2015 ONSC 4431 (CanLII), a rethinking of such approaches may be required. 

Since the Supreme Court's decision in Hryniak v. Mauldin, 2014 SCC 7 (CanLII), summary judgment has become a common tool in straightforward employment law matters. In Hryniak, the Court was explicit that summary judgment should be used whenever there "is no genuine issue requiring a trial."

Read More