Ontario Employment and Labour Law Blog

Search All Articles

Dismissal, Mitigation Kevin Patrick Robbins Dismissal, Mitigation Kevin Patrick Robbins

Time to Expand the Search? The Duty to Mitigate in a Remote Work World

Individuals in Ontario have a duty to mitigate their loss of employment when seeking damages for wrongful (or constructive) dismissal. In practical terms this means that while employees may be able to seek damages from their former employer (to put them in the position they would have been had they received adequate notice of termination), they must make reasonable efforts to replace their lost income by looking for, and accepting, other comparable work.  

Read More
Dismissal, Just Cause Dismissal Kevin Patrick Robbins Dismissal, Just Cause Dismissal Kevin Patrick Robbins

Smoking Gun or Poisoned Chalice? Employee Use of Secret Recordings at Work

As we have written in an earlier article, a relatively common question employment lawyers receive (from both employees and employers) is whether it is lawful to secretly record conversations at work. Individuals may be motivated to take this step for a number of reasons, such as trying to capture evidence of misconduct, or to safeguard against allegations arising from a contentious meeting.

Read More
Wrongful Dismissal, Dismissal Kevin Patrick Robbins Wrongful Dismissal, Dismissal Kevin Patrick Robbins

When is 2.5 Months "Reasonable Notice" of Dismissal?

In wrongful dismissal cases, absent a lawful written contractual entitlement, the courts conduct an individualized assessment to determine what would be reasonable notice of the dismissal. In a recent contribution to First Reference Talks (a collaborative HR and employment law advisory blog), Paul Willetts highlighted two wrongful dismissal cases where the short-service plaintiffs who otherwise differed significantly (in terms of age, compensation and character of employment), both received a 2.5 month notice period.

Read More
Dismissal Kevin Patrick Robbins Dismissal Kevin Patrick Robbins

Top Five Things to Consider When Dismissing an Employee

The decision to terminate an individual’s employment is not an easy one. At times, however, whether due to economic pressures, or poor performance, it may nevertheless be necessary.

The process your organization follows when carrying out a termination of employment is important. It can have a big impact on the affected individual and, if done carefully, can reduce the potential risk of liability to your organization.

Read More
Dismissal, Employee Rights, Employment Contracts Kevin Patrick Robbins Dismissal, Employee Rights, Employment Contracts Kevin Patrick Robbins

Ontario superior court confirms that frustration of contract is a two-way street

The legal doctrine of frustration of contract is well known to employment lawyers but its application is not all that intuitive to the average employer or employee. In the recent case of Hoekstra v. Rehability Occupational Therapy Inc., 2019 ONSC 562, the Ontario Superior Court of Justice was asked to revisit this doctrine and opine as to whether an employee, as compared to an employer, can ever assert frustration to end an employment relationship.

Read More
Wrongful Dismissal, Dismissal, Employment Contracts Kevin Patrick Robbins Wrongful Dismissal, Dismissal, Employment Contracts Kevin Patrick Robbins

Termination clause update: New developments concerning benefit continuation and just cause language

We are not long into 2019 and yet one thing already seems clear – the law concerning employment contract termination clauses will continue to be the focus of a great deal of litigation in Ontario. In just the past few months alone, new decisions from the Superior Court have helped to advance the law and provide further guidance to employers on proper drafting of termination clauses.

Read More
Wrongful Dismissal, Dismissal Kevin Patrick Robbins Wrongful Dismissal, Dismissal Kevin Patrick Robbins

The Pendulum Swings: Wrongful Dismissal and Summary Judgment

Summary judgment can be an invaluable tool for individuals who lose their job. Unlike the traditional litigation route, trudging labouriously through mediation and discoveries to trial, it allows for expedient and cost-effective resolution of straightforward employment disputes.

Rule 20 of the Ontario Rules of Civil Procedure provides for summary judgement "where there is no genuine issue requiring a trial." Last year, following amendments to the rule, the Supreme Court in Hryniak v. Mauldin revisited its application and confirmed that it "must be granted whenever there is no genuine issue requiring a trial."

Read More
Dismissal, Wrongful Dismissal Kevin Patrick Robbins Dismissal, Wrongful Dismissal Kevin Patrick Robbins

Is there now an implied duty to provide reasons for dismissal?

One of the most common complaints employment lawyers hear from workers who have just lost their jobs is that they don't know why they were fired. Many become even more aggravated when they ask for a reason and are told 'we don't have to give you one.' Unsurprisingly, this type of response can often result in the now ex-employee imagining all kinds of innovative rationales as to explain their dismissal.

Pursuant to the Employment Standards Act, which applies to most Ontario employers, there is no requirement to tell dismissed employees' why they are being fired. Accordingly, 'we don't have to tell you' can be a valid response [1].

Read More
Dismissal, Wrongful Dismissal Kevin Patrick Robbins Dismissal, Wrongful Dismissal Kevin Patrick Robbins

Long Service Worker Awarded 27 Months' Severance Pay

It is pretty rare that an employee will receive a severance package worth more than 2-years of their salary. In fact, it is generally agreed that there is an informal '24 month cap' on the amount of pay that a dismissed employee will receive in severance.

That said, there are exceptions to every rule. A recent case from the Ontario Superior Court of Justice, Markoulakis v. SNC Lavalin Inc., illustrates what circumstances may produce a severance entitlement above the 24-month cap.

Read More
Dismissal, Just Cause Dismissal, Wrongful Dismissal Kevin Patrick Robbins Dismissal, Just Cause Dismissal, Wrongful Dismissal Kevin Patrick Robbins

Off-Duty Conduct and Discipline: The FHRITP Case

This week a media firestorm was sparked over comments made by a Hydro One employee (Shawn Simoes) to Shauna Hunt, a CityNews Television Reporter, outside a Toronto F.C. game. Shortly after the televised exchange, Hydro One made the decision to terminate Simoes' employment.

Mr. Simoes was present when another man yelled into Ms. Hunt's Microphone during a live broadcast, "F__k her right in the p___y." Yelling this phrase, abbreviated to FHRITP, was popularized in a series of fake news reports in early 2014. Ms. Hunt, visibly upset at this act, challenged Mr. Simoes and his friends who had stood close by. Mr. Simoes did not repeat the phrase but said on live television to Ms. Hunt that what had transpired was "f____ hilarious." Before adding "you're lucky there's not a f___ vibrator here."

Read More
Dismissal, Just Cause Dismissal Kevin Patrick Robbins Dismissal, Just Cause Dismissal Kevin Patrick Robbins

What is 'Just Cause' for Dismissal?

There is a reason that Canadian courts refer to just cause for dismissal as the "capital punishment of employment law." The implications can be grave. If you are fired for just cause, you will likely face a number of problems. These can include your former employer refusing to provide severance, Service Canada denying your application for Employment Insurance ("EI") benefits and potential negative work references while seeking re-employment.

Read More